Пост 1–6 из 6
1
от
Firefly7 часов тому назад
Earlier this week I received a third-party report about a player's behavior. The report mentioned large scale criminal behavior. I immediately investigated the situation on my side and read a thousand of the player's chat messages. My assessment was that the player was very socially awkward and didn't respect the same social boundaries that I do. I read it as someone being isolated and being overly social. I saw no signs of imminent danger to anyone's life. I saw no signs of criminal intent. I saw no signs of the large operational scope the report claimed. Regardless, I immediately limited the player for a few days to take away their in-game chat. I messaged them about their behavior, explaining what I think they did wrong and how they could do better. Subsequently I started monitoring their chat and their alts every day. I have clear signs they read and understood my message and I haven't seen their problematic behavior return. My finger has been right on the ban-button for when it does. The third-party reporter disagreed with my assessment and approach. I took this seriously and used a local, state-of-the-art LLM to independently classify all of the player's thousands of chat messages to rule out my human bias and shortcomings. With a neutral prompt the LLM summarized: this is an extremely socially awkward and isolated person over-sharing and over-asking. There are no signs of grooming or predatory behavior. I informed the reporter about this. They disagreed with my assessment and approach. They wrote that they did not want to discuss the matter any further. I respected that decision. When it was brought up again on the livestream yesterday I said publicly that I stand by my approach and assessment in this case after spending many hours on it and analyzing thousands of chat messages. What others subsequently did and said is best explained by them. The floor is yours.
от
BlizzySmalls7 часов тому назад
Firefly needs AI to try to understand how he should think. That is crazy
от
BlizzySmalls6 часов тому назад
Firefly, I genuinely don't understand the logic behind your decision not to take appropriate action against a player who has behaved inappropriately toward someone underage. How exactly is this something you can justify? When a situation involves inappropriate conduct toward a minor, it should be treated with the seriousness it deserves. This isn't some petty argument between players, nor is it a matter of someone simply being offended. It's a matter of protecting younger members of your community. As a developer, you have a responsibility to ensure that your game remains a safe environment for its players. That responsibility doesn't disappear when taking action becomes inconvenient. Refusing to address this kind of behaviour sends a terrible message: that players can behave inappropriately toward minors and potentially face no meaningful consequences. What makes this particularly frustrating is the lack of logical consistency. If maintaining a safe community is supposedly important, why would behaviour that directly threatens that safety not warrant serious consideration? What exactly needs to happen before you consider this a problem worth addressing? I'm not asking you to ban someone over a personal disagreement. I'm asking you to recognise the seriousness of inappropriate behaviour directed toward a minor and act accordingly. Please stop treating this as an ordinary player dispute. Review the evidence, explain your reasoning, and take appropriate action. A community's safety should never be secondary to a developer's unwillingness to enforce its own standards. o7
от
obi-4 часов тому назад
I am the 'third-party' reporter. But I received the initial from BlizzySmalls. > The third-party reporter disagreed with my assessment and approach. I did > I took this seriously and used a local, state-of-the-art LLM to independently classify all of the player's thousands of chat messages to rule out my human bias and shortcomings. Yes > With a neutral prompt the LLM summarized: this is an extremely socially awkward and isolated person over-sharing and over-asking. There are no signs of grooming or predatory behavior. > > I informed the reporter about this. They disagreed with my assessment and approach. They wrote that they did not want to discuss the matter any further. I respected that decision. You did not ever mention anything about him being 'socially awkward' or "isolated", what you did say was "I see hints, but nothing concrete". Then the AI analysis you shared was: > I'm dumping it in my local Qwen to analyze and see what I might have missed. > > Overall: some messages and questions inappropriate when aimed at minors. Not clearly predatory, but need to set boundaries. I never got anything else, and I indeed never wanted anything else. --- Before reporting the issue to you I talked to the underage player to see how she felt about the interaction, and I did share my conversation with her with you (I censored her name). The player was banned from the discord server immediately after my conversation with her. Those are the facts, and now my thoughts: You did limit him, because you know he was inappropriate, we all agree on this, you even warned him, the only thing we disagree on is the severity of the punishment. He should have been banned, end of story.
от
Daxi3 часов тому назад
At the end of the day, an LLM is not going to do the decision for you, you have to do it. I know this situation might be quite new for you as it is for most if not all the people in the community right now. Currently almost everyone in the community have voiced their opinion by now and everyone has agreed, with no exception to my knowledge, that this person should be banned. Most people have said it well enough already, you have to draw the line somewhere now and so far you only limited the person for a few days. Even if you give this person the benefit of doubt about what they said, everyone felt it was very weird and most of us felt uncomfortable about it. About a few two dozen people and potentially many more that I have been in conversations with the past few days have disagreed with your approach and with it your decision to only limit this person, agreeing that a ban was necessary. Protecting this one person in a situation that was fortunately noticed by players online at the time sends a bad precedent for future cases like these, and even when this could possibly completely fall under the radar. And this user acting clean and cautious now after they have been limited and put into everyone's attention is no surprise, as even monitored it wouldn't negate past behavior or stop this from happening in that or another account in the future. If the community unanimously agrees the way it did (trust me, no one really disagreed here), you should seriously reconsider your decision into a ban for this player to set a clear line for child safety, that is shown in the terms of service of the game itself and EU laws, as well as protecting the privacy of minors in your game that should align with your constant care for user privacy. It's in your hands to do the right thing, and seeing the community's response, what you did was not enough.
Пост 1–6 из 6
1